Statistics for 2012

By justice →

2026 2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999

Affirmed 238 71.5%

Reversed 50 15%

Affirmed in part, reversed in part 24 7.2%

Opinion issued in a DA case, outcome unknown 9 2.7%

Petition for writ of supervisory control - other with opinion 4 1.2%

Opinion issued dismissing the appeal 2 0.6%

Opinion issued answering a certified question, outcome unknown 1 0.3%

Opinion issued answering a certified question, 'yes' 1 0.3%

Opinion issued dismissing a writ of supervisory control 1 0.3%

Dismissed - case settled in Mediation 1 0.3%

Opinion issued denying a writ of supervisory control 1 0.3%

Opinion issued in an election original proceeding 1 0.3%

First 45 33 · 73.3% 7 · 15.6% 3 · 6.7%

Fourth 40 30 · 75% 4 · 10% 4 · 10%

Thirteenth 39 30 · 76.9% 5 · 12.8% 2 · 5.1%

Twentieth 21 14 · 66.7% 3 · 14.3% 2 · 9.5%

Eighth 20 16 · 80% 1 · 5% 2 · 10%

Eighteenth 19 18 · 94.7% 0 · 0% 0 · 0%

Eleventh 19 9 · 47.4% 7 · 36.8% 2 · 10.5%

Twenty-first 18 11 · 61.1% 3 · 16.7% 4 · 22.2%

Sixteenth 15 11 · 73.3% 3 · 20% 0 · 0%

Nineteenth 14 10 · 71.4% 1 · 7.1% 2 · 14.3%

Ninth 12 6 · 50% 4 · 33.3% 1 · 8.3%

Fifth 10 7 · 70% 3 · 30% 0 · 0%

Twelfth 9 6 · 66.7% 1 · 11.1% 2 · 22.2%

Third 6 5 · 83.3% 1 · 16.7% 0 · 0%

Fourteenth 6 4 · 66.7% 2 · 33.3% 0 · 0%

Second 6 4 · 66.7% 1 · 16.7% 0 · 0%

Twenty-second 6 6 · 100% 0 · 0% 0 · 0%

Seventh 5 2 · 40% 3 · 60% 0 · 0%

Tenth 4 3 · 75% 0 · 0% 0 · 0%

Sixth 4 3 · 75% 1 · 25% 0 · 0%

Seventeenth 4 4 · 100% 0 · 0% 0 · 0%

Workers Compensation Court 3 3 · 100% 0 · 0% 0 · 0%

Fifteenth 3 3 · 100% 0 · 0% 0 · 0%

U.S. District Court-Montana 2 0 · 0% 0 · 0% 0 · 0%

All opinions 333 289d 96d 21d — Opposed to I-166 v. Bullock 1044d — Grant Cr. v. Missoula Co

Five-justice panel 302 285d 92d 21d — Opposed to I-166 v. Bullock 1044d — Grant Cr. v. Missoula Co

En banc 23 293d 110d 58d — Reichert, et al. vs. State 477d — In the Matter of M.W

Oral argument 28 398d 208d 188d — Am. Zurich Ins. v. 13th Judicial District 655d — Western Tradition v. Attorney General

Criminal 97 345d 98d 144d — State v. Brandon Burns (DC 99-0351) 622d — Longjaw v. State

Five-justice panel 89 345d 97d 144d — State v. Brandon Burns (DC 99-0351) 622d — Longjaw v. State

En banc 7 316d 89d 198d — State v. Green 445d — City of Whitefish v. Ralph Jentile

Oral argument 4 473d 222d 392d — State v. Benn 526d — State v. Derek Bishop

Civil 236 265d 95d 21d — Opposed to I-166 v. Bullock 1044d — Grant Cr. v. Missoula Co

Five-justice panel 213 259d 90d 21d — Opposed to I-166 v. Bullock 1044d — Grant Cr. v. Missoula Co

En banc 16 283d 119d 58d — Reichert, et al. vs. State 477d — In the Matter of M.W

Oral argument 24 385d 206d 188d — Am. Zurich Ins. v. 13th Judicial District 655d — Western Tradition v. Attorney General

Kluver, et al. v. PPL Mt, et al 2012 MT 321 DA 11-0681 · Dec 31, 2012 · Affirmed MW MG BB JR BM JN PC

Big Sky Colony v. Doli 2012 MT 320 DA 11-0572 · Dec 31, 2012 · Reversed BM MG MW BB JN JR PC

McEwen v. Mcr 2012 MT 319 DA 11-0722 · Dec 31, 2012 · Affirmed in part, reversed in part BM MG BB MW JR JN PC

Marsden v. Bcbsmt 2012 MT 306 DA 12-0341 · Dec 28, 2012 · Affirmed BM MG BB MW JR

Rebecca Mattson, et al. v. Montana Power Co., et al 2012 MT 318 DA 11-0413 · Dec 27, 2012 · Reversed JN MG MW PC BM BB JR

State v. Stewart 2012 MT 317 DA 11-0254 · Dec 27, 2012 · Affirmed JN PC MW BB JR

Sees the Ground v. State 2012 MT 315N DA 12-0291 · Dec 27, 2012 · Affirmed MW MG PC BM BB

State v. Leslie Jon Claassen 2012 MT 313 DA 12-0162 · Dec 27, 2012 · Affirmed MW MG PC BM JR

State v. Kenneth Nixon 2012 MT 316 DA 11-0611 · Dec 27, 2012 · Affirmed MW BB PC BM JR

Tonner v. Cirian 2012 MT 314 DA 12-0178 · Dec 27, 2012 · Reversed BB MG MW BM JR

Labair v. Carey, et al 2012 MT 312 DA 11-0755 · Dec 27, 2012 · Reversed PC MG MW BM JN JR BB

Jones v. Shaurette 2012 MT 310N DA 12-0153 · Dec 27, 2012 · Affirmed in part, reversed in part MG BB PC MW JR

Swapinski v. Hubbard 2012 MT 309N DA 12-0259 · Dec 27, 2012 · Affirmed MG JR MW PC BM

Marriage of Churchill 2012 MT 311N DA 12-0177 · Dec 27, 2012 · Affirmed

Evans v. Dow 2012 MT 308N DA 12-0110 · Dec 26, 2012 · Affirmed JR MG MW BB BM